Home > Uncategorized > Where REALLY is the fair sex at the workplace?

Where REALLY is the fair sex at the workplace?

July 31st, 2009

A recent research study shows that the number of women members on the Corporate Boards of organizations in India is a mere 4%. (Source: Review of the balance sheets of 175 companies). The study throws up another interesting fact - 50% of women Board members are related to the Chairman or CEO either as mother, sister, wife or daughter. This means that just 2% of the members have attained the top position in organizations.

The National Census conducted across the country every 10 years shows that close to 50% of the overall population in India is women. In the last couple of decades, there has been a steady and significant increase in the number of women joining the workforce. This has been catapulted by the emergence and rapid growth of the services sector, that has provided a better working environment for women and leveraged their natural talents, that the factories and manufacturing facilities could not, unless it was say a high-technology/pharmaceutical plant.

Another important thing to note is that in India, there have been exclusive women’s colleges in existence for decades. In fact, some of them have been established even before India attained its freedom from British rule. To quote a few examples, Women’s Christian College in Chennai (founded in 1915), Women’s Christian College, Kolkata (1945), St. .Xaviers, Mumbai (1868), Women’s College, Kolkata (1937), Mount Caramel Bangalore (1948). Several colleges celebrated their Golden Jubilee years in the last few years, e.g. the Lady Shri Ram in 2005. Such colleges have been a lighthouse of learning and significantly for the nation, have been successfully producing a large number of women graduates and post graduates. Besides these prestigious institutes which continue to be held with great esteem, a large number of medical, engineering and management schools have come up, which have a good proportion of girl students.

So if there’s such a rich woman talent pool and there are industries that provide a better enabling environment for women employees, the million dollar question is – where are all these well educated women, and why are they not among the top positions in organizations?

An obvious response – which definitely has more than a grain of truth at least in the Indian context – is that the majority of them have preferred to become home makers at some stage in their career, and only a few really focused on building their careers as a long term commitment, like men do.

Is it because women experience the pain of a ‘glass ceiling’ to reach senior levels – something that is never talked about or blatantly visible, but only to be felt, experienced, and that too only by women employees. Several Western countries have been having debates on whether such a glass ceiling indeed exists…do such discussions happen in India? Is it high time such a dialog started in India?

Let’s look at India a little more closely. Traditionally in India, educated women  have been employed as nurses, teachers, secretaries, and bank employees. The new economy sectors such as IT and ITES have provided employment opportunities for women like none before. At ‘skilled category’ level, a small percentage of women work in facilities like precision component assembly units, where the dexterity with which they use their fingers make them a perfect fit for the role. Then, of course there are industries like apparel, fashion, jewelry, advertising, etc, that play to the creative talents in women.

Over the last decade, realizing the benefits of having a diverse workforce for business performance, several global organizations have started Diversity programs. One common initiative is to make conscious efforts to increase the percentage of women at various levels in their organizations – in other words, diversity metrics like % women in the workforce.

However, it must be said that through all these efforts, we are only scratching at the surface as the corporate world is missing out on a large productive population out there who’s still not part of the labor force.

Here’s where I’d like to ask - Can we as HR professionals, revisit some of the moth-balled excuses and prejudices that still exist for not recruiting women, e.g. “The moment she gets married, she’d leave her job’, ‘she takes leave often to attend to her family needs, ‘she can’t work late in case of urgent deadlines’, ‘Maternity leave is expensive and it means I will not have a team member for 90 days or more, ‘she can’t go on tours’, ‘a majority of women are not REALLY serious about their careers”…and so on.

Wearing the hat of a pragmatist, in today’s context, dual household income has almost become a must due to factors like increasing consumerism, high cost of living, a strong desire to ‘do the best’ for our children, e.g. providing best possible schooling and facilities to our children, etc…In such a situation, can women from middle class families afford not to consider having a working  career and be content just being a homemaker?

Can we then be aware and reflect upon our own biases, prejudices and fears as HR professionals and human beings? Before we convince the line managers and the top management, it’s important that we have a strong conviction that having a greater representation of women in our organization will lead to improved business performance and foster harmony at the workplace.

So, when we are next hiring for a position, let’s ask ourselves: Can this responsibilities of this position be carried out well by both a competent man or woman?

Uncategorized

  1. S.Y. Siddiqui
    August 17th, 2009 at 06:44 | #1

    Dear Dr. Murthy,

    First of all I complement you for writing this excellent blog, I found it
    quite interesting specially your finding on the number of women members on
    Board in Corporate India, however, it is surprising that only 4% women are
    employed in Indian Corporate but the fact that just 2% of the members have
    attained the top position in organizations without having any relation with
    the Chairman and CEO is really alarming.

    We all know that in India we have had exclusive women’s colleges in
    existence for decades and these have been successfully adding a large number
    of women graduates and post graduates, however in my view if you compare the
    number of these colleges with the number of colleges where male domination
    is present we will find a huge skew. If you look at the top engineering
    colleges like IIT’s, NIT’s and business schools like IIM’s, the percentage
    of women is extremely low. Women professionals passed out from such
    institutes are doing extremely well, but if you analyze the gender ratio it
    is again low against males.

    Considering the fact that students from top institutes often succeed in the
    corporate career, the low percentage of female student in these institutes
    is also being reflected in the top management in Indian organizations and
    unfortunately that is also male dominated as of now. Apart from this the
    reasons such as biases, prejudices and fears in the mind of people are the
    other major factors which might be holding women back, as you have also
    pointed out.

    I also agree with the glass ceiling in organizations which might be
    hindering women to move upwards in the corporate leadership role, but again
    this ceiling is lot to do with biases, prejudices and fears in the minds of
    people. There is no doubt that having a greater representation of women in
    Indian organization will lead to improved business performance and foster
    harmony at the workplace, especially considering the capabilities and talent
    which females are housed with. We have various examples today which
    certainly would shatter the myths held by people who still believe that the
    capability of women employees is in any way less than their male
    counterparts.

    To conclude I would say that we need to make conscious efforts to increase
    the percentage of women at various levels in Corporate India. However I
    would like to add that we need to lay focus at the sourcing channels from
    where we can generate women managers and ensure that there is diversity and
    not as skewed as it currently is. But I also think that no one from the sky
    will come to help and rescue the women from this situation, it is the women
    who need to take a call with conviction, commitment, clear understanding and
    strong determination that what kind to life they want to build and live for
    themselves.

    Warm Regards,

    Siddiqui

  2. August 25th, 2009 at 04:25 | #2

    Dear Dr.Murthy,

    I found your blog interesting.

    Just to add a couple of points from my end, this issue as an HR can be looked from two angles. One is that, as you have suggested, the common look that most of of the HR’s take like, ML proves dearer, no resource for 90 days….etc., The other view would be that looking from an Indian context is that, the Indian society for that matter majority of the societies across the world are male dominated and we lest tend to forget that it is only due to the efforts and patience of women managing the home and the family is that men are managing and accomplishing in the outer world. This may not hold good in all the situations. As an HR, if we are sensitive to this point, I presume down the line, we will find many more Kiran Nooyi, Kiran Majumdar Shaw….

  3. Mohan M Prasad
    September 8th, 2009 at 03:25 | #3

    Dear Dr. Murthy,

    Your article is quite thought provoking.

    There seems to be a big yarning gap in the organization hierarchy between cradles and the glass ceilings; between the colleges and the corporate world.

    The trends of a healthy mix are getting messed up.….

    While your suggestion to reflect is quite sound, I would like to give the cue a direction which is inward looking and inside in.
    Before we preach we should have a demonstrated practice in our home town – HR team.
    How many qualified and/or experienced women HR Professional form a part of the HR Department? Are we outside the biases, prejudices and fears?

    The answer would beg the question

    If we as a fraternity and community of HR professionals commit to be cast out by the conviction of inclusive outlook ,convincing becomes far more easier and our demonstrated conduct in inducting the women members will create the desired percolation effect across the organization .

    We need to take the lead within ourselves and facilitate fostering this rich thought and excercise on a commitment to be “FAIR TO THE FAIR SEX “.

    Let’s make the beginning towards this endeavor that will definitely promote harmony at the work place.

    “Where the corporate world is not broken up into fragments by narrow gender walls”

    Warm regards

    Mohan M Prasad
    PS: I did a quick count of my team and I am as guilty of this prejudice as many of my peers are likely to be. Here is my turning point.
    Thanks Dr. Once gain.

  1. No trackbacks yet.